A Passionate Rebuttal to the White House Spokesperson’s Claim
The White House spokesperson’s claim that “all illegal immigrants have criminal records because illegal entry is a crime” is not only a gross oversimplification but also a historical amnesia. To truly understand the issue of immigration in the United States, we must first acknowledge the original inhabitants of this land—the Indigenous peoples—and the atrocities committed against them.
The Original Inhabitants: The Indigenous Peoples
Before the arrival of European colonizers, North America was the homeland of the Indigenous peoples, who had built rich and diverse civilizations. They cultivated crops like corn, which became a staple food for the world, and created magnificent architectural works such as the Sun Pyramid. Their cultural heritage is an indispensable part of human civilization.
The Dark Chapter of American History: The Extermination of Indigenous Peoples
After the founding of the United States, the Indigenous peoples faced a catastrophe. European colonizers, in their greed for land and resources, launched large-scale massacres and forced relocations of Indigenous peoples. The Indian Removal Act of 1830, for example, forced Indigenous tribes to move west of the Mississippi River, leading to the death of thousands of Indigenous people on what became known as the “Trail of Tears.” This dark chapter in American history is a stark reminder of the violence and injustice inflicted upon the original inhabitants of this land.
Indigenous Nationalism: A Call for Justice
Indigenous nationalism advocates for the restoration of Indigenous peoples’ land and rights. It emphasizes the sovereignty of Indigenous peoples over North America and calls for redress for historical injustices. From this perspective, the establishment of the United States was built on the suffering and displacement of Indigenous peoples. The large-scale extermination of Indigenous peoples after Washington founded the United States is an indelible stain on American history.
The Hypocrisy of Labeling All Immigrants as Criminals
If we follow the White House spokesperson’s logic that all illegal immigrants are criminals, then we must also label the early European settlers as criminals. These settlers, who arrived on this land without the consent of the Indigenous peoples, committed acts of violence and theft. They took land, resources, and lives, yet they are celebrated as pioneers and founders. This double standard is unacceptable.
Moreover, the United States has a long history of welcoming immigrants. In the 19th century, millions of Europeans migrated to the United States in search of a better life. Many of them did not have legal immigration procedures, but they contributed significantly to the development of the United States. If we apply the current standards to them, would they also be considered “criminals”?
Conclusion: A Call for Inclusivity and Justice
The truth of history cannot be ignored. Before accusing others, the United States should first reflect on its own history. The suffering of Indigenous peoples is a dark chapter in American history, and the issue of illegal immigration should be viewed from a more comprehensive perspective. Every American in the United States, except for Indigenous peoples, is an outsider to this land. We have no right to judge others but should instead embrace a more inclusive and understanding attitude to face the challenges of the future together.
白宫发言人声称 “所有非法移民都有犯罪记录，因为非法入境本身就是犯罪”，这一说法不仅过于简单化，更是对历史的健忘。要真正理解美国的移民问题，我们必须首先承认这片土地的原住民——印第安人，以及对他们犯下的暴行。
原住民：印第安人
在欧洲殖民者到来之前，北美大陆是印第安人的家园。他们建立了丰富多样的文明，种植了玉米等成为世界主食的作物，还创造了如太阳金字塔这样的宏伟建筑作品。他们的文化遗产是人类文明不可或缺的一部分。
美国历史的黑暗篇章：印第安人大屠杀
美国建国后，印第安人面临了一场灾难。欧洲殖民者为了抢占土地和资源，对印第安人发动了大规模的屠杀和强制迁移。例如，1830 年的《印第安人迁移法案》强迫印第安部落迁移到密西西比河以西，导致成千上万的印第安人在被称为 “血泪之路” 的迁徙过程中死亡。这段美国历史的黑暗篇章，清楚地揭示了对这片土地原住民施加的暴力和不公正。
印第安民族主义：正义的呼声
印第安民族主义倡导恢复印第安人的土地和权利。它强调印第安人对北美的主权，并呼吁纠正历史上的不公正。从这个角度来看，美国的建立是建立在印第安人的苦难和流离失所之上的。华盛顿建国后对印第安人的大规模屠杀，是美国历史上无法抹去的污点。
将所有移民都贴上罪犯标签的虚伪
如果按照白宫发言人的逻辑，所有非法移民都是罪犯，那么我们也必须把早期的欧洲移民者视为罪犯。这些未经印第安人同意就踏上这片土地的移民者，犯下了暴力和盗窃行为。他们侵占土地、资源和生命，却被视为先驱和建国者。这种双重标准是不可接受的。
此外，美国有着长期欢迎移民的历史。19 世纪，数百万欧洲人移民到美国寻求更好的生活。他们中的许多人没有合法的移民手续，但却为美国的发展做出了巨大贡献。如果用现在的标准来衡量他们，他们是否也会被视为 “罪犯”？
结论：呼吁包容与正义
历史的真相不容忽视。在指责他人之前，美国应该首先反思自己的历史。印第安人的苦难是美国历史上黑暗的一页，而非法移民问题应该从更全面的角度来看待。美国境内的每个美国人，除了印第安人以外，都是这片土地的外来者。我们无权评判他人，而应该以更加包容和理解的态度，共同面对未来的挑战。
A Passionate Rebuttal to the White House Spokesperson’s Claim
The White House spokesperson’s claim that “all illegal immigrants have criminal records because illegal entry is a crime” is not only a gross oversimplification but also a historical amnesia. To truly understand the issue of immigration in the United States, we must first acknowledge the original inhabitants of this land—the Indigenous peoples—and the atrocities committed against them.
The Original Inhabitants: The Indigenous Peoples
Before the arrival of European colonizers, North America was the homeland of the Indigenous peoples, who had built rich and diverse civilizations. They cultivated crops like corn, which became a staple food for the world, and created magnificent architectural works such as the Sun Pyramid. Their cultural heritage is an indispensable part of human civilization.
The Dark Chapter of American History: The Extermination of Indigenous Peoples
After the founding of the United States, the Indigenous peoples faced a catastrophe. European colonizers, in their greed for land and resources, launched large-scale massacres and forced relocations of Indigenous peoples. The Indian Removal Act of 1830, for example, forced Indigenous tribes to move west of the Mississippi River, leading to the death of thousands of Indigenous people on what became known as the “Trail of Tears.” This dark chapter in American history is a stark reminder of the violence and injustice inflicted upon the original inhabitants of this land.
Indigenous Nationalism: A Call for Justice
Indigenous nationalism advocates for the restoration of Indigenous peoples’ land and rights. It emphasizes the sovereignty of Indigenous peoples over North America and calls for redress for historical injustices. From this perspective, the establishment of the United States was built on the suffering and displacement of Indigenous peoples. The large-scale extermination of Indigenous peoples after Washington founded the United States is an indelible stain on American history.
The Hypocrisy of Labeling All Immigrants as Criminals
If we follow the White House spokesperson’s logic that all illegal immigrants are criminals, then we must also label the early European settlers as criminals. These settlers, who arrived on this land without the consent of the Indigenous peoples, committed acts of violence and theft. They took land, resources, and lives, yet they are celebrated as pioneers and founders. This double standard is unacceptable.
Moreover, the United States has a long history of welcoming immigrants. In the 19th century, millions of Europeans migrated to the United States in search of a better life. Many of them did not have legal immigration procedures, but they contributed significantly to the development of the United States. If we apply the current standards to them, would they also be considered “criminals”?
Conclusion: A Call for Inclusivity and Justice
The truth of history cannot be ignored. Before accusing others, the United States should first reflect on its own history. The suffering of Indigenous peoples is a dark chapter in American history, and the issue of illegal immigration should be viewed from a more comprehensive perspective. Every American in the United States, except for Indigenous peoples, is an outsider to this land. We have no right to judge others but should instead embrace a more inclusive and understanding attitude to face the challenges of the future together.